County says no contract in the works, only high-level discussions
Greenville County officials are discussing the possibility of streamlining the county’s emergency response system by giving Greenville Health System (GHS) a role in the operation of Greenville County’s Emergency Medical Services.
Bon Secours St. Francis CEO Mark Nantz said his system is concerned about the potential for a monopoly if GHS is the sole provider of EMS services in the county. St. Francis has approximately 33 percent of the health care market in the area and a fair amount of patients come through via ambulance, Nantz told the Upstate Business Journal.
He would like to see an independent entity, neither St. Francis nor GHS, operate the EMS service. “Giving the keys to the transportation vehicle to my competitor, that just didn’t feel right to me,” Nantz told UBJ.
The decision also touches on patient choice, Nantz said. He suggested a separate nonprofit collaboration if the county does not want to run EMS. St. Francis officials offered to bear some of the financial burden of providing the service in a collaborative arrangement, said Nantz.
Making one health system the sole provider could lead to a lower quality service and higher costs due to lack of competition, Nantz said.
Greenville County’s EMS department makes up roughly $16 million of the county budget and operates at an approximate $4 million loss, documents show. The county’s EMS service has 202 full time positions and operates 27 ambulances, according to the county.
Nantz said Bon Secours St. Francis has repeatedly requested over the past two years to be part of the discussion of changes in the county’s EMS operations, but were often dismissed or excluded. Nantz said nearly 17 percent of St. Francis’ admissions now come through the ER and hospital officials are concerned that could decrease if EMS workers are employed by GHS.
“We made it very clear we wanted to be part of this,” Nantz said. He said St. Francis was told it “would be taken care of,” but had no details about what that meant. “It is clear to us that Bon Secours St. Francis has been intentionally excluded and kept in the dark since the beginning of these deliberations,” he said.
GHS issued a statement from Dr. Angelo Sinopoli, chief medical officer, saying the issue is what benefits the county best.
“It’s not about competition between hospitals – it is about how to provide the best emergency services for all patients regardless of where they receive their care,” the statement said. “Greenville Health System has been working with community partners like EMS for years and has provided medical management for EMS for more than 30 years. The professionalism of the EMS staff and the innovation of Greenville County has allowed us to move forward with innovative approaches that help our community. We believe our focus on value, patient choice and clinical excellence has made a difference.”
Greenville County administrator Joe Kernell told UBJ that both health care systems have been part of county discussions. The county is evaluating the EMS service, but not because it is operating at a loss, he said. “We’re looking at how we can provide the best EMS emergency health care that we possibly can.”
Kernell said discussions are not as far along as St. Francis claims and no contract has been drafted between the county and GHS. He said has not presented anything to council, but only had “high-level discussions so far” that have included St. Francis.
“We have talked with both hospitals,” Kernell said. “We are talking with GHS right now. They are a quasi-governmental body and we are a governmental body. We can contract for services with other governmental bodies if it works out. St. Francis is a private hospital.”
It is “very premature” to talk about signing a contract, though one could be executed fairly quickly, Kernell said.
The EMS department could continue the way it is now without any action, he said. “The county has a very good EMS service currently. We operate a very high-level EMS service. All we’ve been doing is exploring the future of EMS. We don’t have to do anything, we can continue what we’re doing now and everything is fine.
“As good stewards, we are looking at what is the best fit and what is the best operation for EMS in the future. We’re exploring what the options may be,” he said.
Asked about the potential structure of a collaboration with GHS, Kernell said, “We haven’t gotten anywhere near there yet to answer those types of questions. Those are the kinds of things we’re starting to discuss.”
The county has looked into using GHS’s Mobile Care non-emergency ambulance service to supplement the county operations and “provide better coverage,” Kernell said.
St. Francis board chair Camilla Hertwig said the discussion process has not been transparent and it should be because it concerns the health of county residents.
Hertwig referenced a study conducted by Washko and Associates last year, “Greenville County Pre-Hospital Care and Transport System,” that evaluated the county EMS operations and outlined future options.
The study examined everything from response time to peak call times. Course of action options included privatization, public/private partnership, nonprofit joint venture, public utility model or fail-safe franchise model.
The study also outlines a proposed course of action for integrating Greenville County operations with Mobile Care (GHS), but does not mention involvement by St. Francis.